Rights group notes pattern of anti-Muslim violence in Indian state
Fact-finding report says Muslim communities faced targeted attacks, selective law enforcement and collective punishment in BJP-ruled Himalayan state
NEW DELHI, India (MNTV) — A civil rights investigation has documented what it describes as a pattern of targeted violence against Muslim communities in Uttarakhand, a northern Indian state governed by the Hindu nationalist Bharatiya Janata Party, citing police inaction, selective enforcement of laws and administrative measures that disproportionately affected minorities.
The findings are detailed in a report released by the Association for Protection of Civil Rights (APCR), which examined incidents since late 2023 across multiple districts, including Uttarkashi, Dehradun, Haridwar, Nainital, Haldwani and Udham Singh Nagar, as well as forest areas inhabited by Van Gujjar pastoral communities.
According to the report, Muslim-owned homes, shops and religious sites were disproportionately targeted during episodes of unrest that included arson, vandalism, stone-pelting and threats of eviction.
Several incidents followed Hindutva rallies or rumors framed around Muslim religious identity, a pattern the authors say has become increasingly common in parts of northern India.
Investigators said police presence frequently failed to prevent violence and that first information reports were often delayed or selectively registered.
In multiple cases, Muslim residents were reportedly detained under preventive legal provisions aimed at maintaining “law and order,” while individuals accused of delivering inflammatory speeches at public gatherings faced little or no immediate legal action, despite video footage circulating publicly.
The report highlights the use of prohibitory orders and preventive detention measures that were imposed largely on Muslim neighborhoods after communal tensions, while organizers of Hindu right-wing rallies were rarely subjected to comparable restrictions. This, the authors argue, points to discriminatory policing rather than neutral crowd control.
Beyond policing, the report flags what it describes as the growing use of collective punishment, including administrative notices threatening demolition, sealing of properties or eviction, sometimes issued without prior notice or a hearing. Such actions, it says, bypass constitutional safeguards and deepen the marginalization of minority communities.
The social and economic impact has been significant. Many Muslim families temporarily fled their homes due to fear, with women, children and daily-wage workers among the worst affected. Disruptions to livelihoods and schooling were reported in several localities.
Situating Uttarakhand within a wider national trend, the report warns that administrative authority is increasingly being deployed alongside majoritarian mobilization in BJP-ruled states, normalizing the targeting of Muslims through both violence and governance mechanisms.
It calls for independent judicial inquiries, accountability for hate speech and stricter adherence to constitutional protections to prevent further escalation.