Vacant posts, unqualified teachers: Inside the collapse of philosophy education in Pakistan
With most university philosophy posts vacant and curricula fragmented, students are left with disconnected courses, selective readings, and no coherent training in critical thinking
By Mushfiq Ahmed
KARACHI, Pakistan (MNTV) – Pakistan’s philosophy education is facing a severe structural breakdown, as universities struggle to fill long-vacant posts, rely on unqualified instructors, and drift away from systematic curricula once considered academically rigorous.
Conversation with Dr Abdul Wahab Suri, a senior philosophy teacher, on the World Philosophy Day revealed a portrait of a discipline declining not because of weak student interest alone, but because the state has slowly abandoned the institutions that once sustained genuine philosophical training.
Across the country, philosophy is now taught in only “five or six places,” including Karachi University, Shah Abdul Latif University Khairpur (referred to as “Salu”), Punjab University, Government College University (GCU) Lahore, and Peshawar University.
Elite private institutions like LUMS and IBA offer philosophy only as individual courses, not as a degree. Even universities where philosophy is taught seriously at the course level — such as Habib University — do not award degrees in the subject.
Suri argues that this fractured model produces confusion: students may take disconnected philosophy courses as part of their general social science degrees, but never encounter the discipline as a coherent system.
“Studying philosophy as unrelated elective subjects is a waste of time,” he said, noting that students often cite thinkers selectively, mixing ideas without understanding context.
One example he gave was students speaking about feminism while quoting authors who, in their original texts, do not even consider women as fully human. “People read a bit of Leviathan here, a bit of Das Kapital there, and think they understand philosophy.”
‘Attack religion’
Suri recalled that state universities once offered structured, difficult, and deeply grounded curricula — “38 philosophy courses” that students had to pass, even if many were outside their personal interests.
These programs, he said, trained generations of scholars who learned to “think from zero,” thanks to strong faculty who were PhD-trained abroad and who taught with academic seriousness.
But those teachers were hired under a state that still believed in cultivating thinkers. “They used to say: ‘the Government of Pakistan pays me to think’,” he recalled. That sense of purpose has withered. “Priorities have changed.”
Departments were asked to teach philosophy in the manner it was being marketed elsewhere: de-contextualized, issue-based, and lacking methodological grounding. Instead of dialectics, logic, or evolutionary development of ideas, students now receive fragmented themes with no internal coherence. “A child walks away with one line: question everything — usually meaning, attack religion.”
The most alarming problem is the collapse of faculty numbers. One major department he described once had 14 sanctioned positions, but only seven remain filled. The rest have been vacant for more than a decade.
Retirements in 2015, 2018, and 2025 were never replaced. “These seven positions have been empty since 2013,” Suri said. “People retired, and no one was appointed.”
Across the country, the pattern is the same. Peshawar University has “three or four teachers,” Quetta University also “three or four,” and Punjab University “five or six.” Many more are required — “twelve to fourteen” in each major university — but appointments have stalled.
Talented graduates who applied in response to a job advertisement in 2019 are still waiting. “Six years have passed,” he said. One top student ended up teaching at a school, where philosophy is not even offered; he now teaches “Critical Studies” or introductory psychology simply to earn a living.
A system weakened by provincial expansion
The professor links much of the collapse to the post-18th Amendment expansion of universities. All four provinces opened dozens of new institutions — “25 universities” — as part of political patronage and resource distribution.
Many have no philosophy departments at all; instead, they employ individual teachers with backgrounds in unrelated fields.
“HEC said philosophy and ethics for non-Muslims should be taught after the War on Terror,” Suri said. But instead of strengthening departments, universities simply assigned these courses to whoever was available. “Someone from sociology, someone from English literature, someone from Urdu literature — everyone is teaching philosophy.”
This practice, he warned, produces distortion. Some teachers misuse or misplace philosophical arguments, quote Marx to defend capitalism, or selectively cite religious thinkers. “Every philosopher has a sanctity,” he said. “At least use Marx against capitalism, not to justify it.” Selective reading, he said, erodes intellectual honesty.
The private sector: instrumental philosophy
Private universities offer another type of dilution. Philosophy is taught “instrumentally” — not as a discipline but as a toolkit. According to Suri, this produces students skilled in instrumental reasoning but lacking commitment to ideas or Islamic traditions.
Many courses focus on micro-topics including feminist semantics or postmodern fragments, without grounding students in feminism, radicalism, post-feminism, or structural concepts.
The result, he said, is “disorientation” and a generation easily “used” — encouraged to attack traditions without understanding the philosophical foundations they come from. “They learn to babble, not to think.”
In some institutions, there is not even a single full professor left. GCU Lahore — once a prestigious institution that produced major thinkers — now has no philosophy professor at all.
The professor fears that Pakistan has collectively decided it no longer needs thought. Without strong public philosophy departments, he said, the country will depend on social scientists who cannot project large-scale ideas, and private-sector graduates trained only in fragmented, instrumental frameworks.