Analysts say evidence points to downing of Indian jets
As India stays silent on reported jet losses, international experts cite wreckage, witness accounts, and official suppression as signs Islamabad’s claims may hold weight
MNTV Analysis
As India continues to remain silent on Pakistan’s claim of shooting down five of its fighter jets, international analysts argue that growing evidence — from images of burning wreckage to regional witness accounts — increasingly points to Indian air force assets having been downed.
“Until evidence comes out to the contrary, I think it’s reasonable to assume this is an IAF (Indian air force) jet because Indian authorities have had [roughly] five hours to say otherwise,” said Christopher Clary, a non-resident fellow at the Stimson Centre think tank, speaking to The Telegraph.
His remarks reflect a growing belief that India’s silence may indicate acknowledgment of losses too politically costly to admit.
According to The Telegraph’s Memphis Barker, local officials confirmed to global news outlets that three Indian jets had crashed in Indian-administered Kashmir.
A similar report briefly appeared in The Hindu, one of India’s leading national dailies, but was quickly removed.
The newspaper later issued a retraction and apology, citing editorial error and clarifying there was “no such on-record official confirmation from India.”
The sudden deletion raised suspicion among media observers and defence analysts.
Despite the lack of official acknowledgment, frontline evidence surfaced.
Photojournalist Dar Yasin reached the crash site outside Srinagar and captured an image of what appeared to be a discarded drop tank from an Indian fighter jet.
He was prevented by authorities from moving closer to the main wreckage, but locals at the site told him they had seen a “huge ball of fire” and burning debris for hours.
Several videos of the wreckage circulated on social media before being taken down and access restricted.
Was it a French Rafale?
Aerospace analyst Andreas Rupprecht, quoted in The Telegraph, noted that one image from the wreckage appeared to show an M88 engine — used in French-made Rafale jets flown by the Indian Air Force.
Roughly 600 kilometres south in Punjab’s Akhali Kurd village, residents were shaken awake by a loud explosion in the early hours.
The Indian Express reported that locals discovered scattered aircraft wreckage. The Indian army swiftly moved in to cordon off the area, and a civilian was reportedly killed in a secondary blast while filming debris.
Analysts noted that Akhali Kurd is just 50 miles from Barnala — one of the areas Pakistan claims to have targeted.
“We shot jets down in Akhoor, Ambala, Barnala and in Jammu,” declared Pakistan’s Information Minister Attaullah Tarar at an early morning press briefing.
“We also shot down quadcopters and a big drone.”
CNN also quoted a government official and local resident in Indian-administered Kashmir who confirmed that a fighter jet had crashed onto a school building.
A senior French intelligence official confirmed to CNN that one Rafale fighter jet operated by the Indian Air Force was downed by Pakistan—potentially marking the first combat loss of the highly advanced French-made warplane.
The revelation adds weight to Pakistan’s earlier claim that it had shot down five Indian jets in retaliation for cross-border strikes, including three Rafales. So far, New Delhi has offered no official response.
French authorities are now investigating whether additional Rafales were also brought down during the overnight confrontation. The aircraft’s manufacturer, Dassault Aviation, has declined to comment on the reports or media inquiries.
India had inducted 36 Rafale jets into its Air Force prior to this escalation. The twin-engine, 10-ton fighter is among the most sophisticated in its class, equipped with air-to-air missiles, cruise missiles, laser-guided bombs, and a 30mm cannon.
While the French military has yet to issue a formal statement, the incident could have far-reaching implications for the Rafale’s combat record and ongoing defence partnerships.
AFP photographs showed debris strewn beside a red-brick structure, although the identity of the aircraft could not be confirmed visually.
While Indian authorities have said that all pilots returned safely from the mission, they have not confirmed or denied whether any aircraft were lost or pilots had to eject.
As The Telegraph’s Barker noted, past India-Pakistan escalations have generally followed a tit-for-tat script that stops short of full war.
“If it has indeed shot down several Indian jets,” he writes, “Operation Sindoor could be as much of a victory for Islamabad as its old enemy across the border.”
With neither side willing to fully reveal the truth, the fog of war continues to obscure clarity. But amid satellite imagery, eyewitness accounts, expert analysis and missing official denials, many across the world are drawing their own conclusions.